It’s a chilly Tuesday night in Columbia, South Carolina, and fans of the minor league baseball team Columbia Fireflies are letting opposing batter Marcos Torres listen.
“Marco!” A fan calls.
“Polo!” A half-dozen fans responded by simulating a swimming pool game.
The batsman swings and misses. The whirling begins again.
“Marco!”
“Polo!”
Baseball fans have developed a popularity for chanting wisecracks to attempt to rile up players. But heckling has a dark side, which bothers me. As a sports, media and mental health researcher: When fans cross the road from playful banter to verbal abuse.
The most up-to-date publicized incident occurred during a game between the Boston Red Sox and the Minnesota Twins on April 14, 2026. A fan within the stands at Target Field in Minneapolis Red Sox outfielder Jaren Doran was reportedly told to kill himself. Duran replied giving him the finger.
It was at least the second time. Since the 2025 release of the Netflix documentary, a fan has used Duran’s mental health as verbal ammunition.Clubhouse: A Year with the Red Sox” during which Duran described a suicide attempt.
After the sport, Doran told reporters, “Honestly, it’s my fault for talking about my mental health, because I kind of brought on the haters.”
American society holds elite athletes in high esteem. They are uniquely trustworthy and admirable.. That’s why they’re seen as spokespersons for all the pieces from automotive insurance to foot powder. And that is why so many children Look to athletes as role models.
So when someone like Doran is harassed after disclosing a mental illness – after which regrets opening up – an impressionable bystander might determine that talking about their mental health struggles is not well worth the risk.
Most fans respond positively.
Elite sports could cause stress. In addition to the pressure to perform, there are travel, training and relationship management requirements. In this cut-throat environment, your substitute is commonly waiting to come upon you. So it’s no surprise that athletes have long felt compelled to cover any sign of weakness or weakness, including mental health.
The routines in sports are changing, though, perhaps partially due to the changes Public attitudes toward mental illness. Social media has also allowed athletes to attach directly with fans, allowing for greater insight into the human being behind the hero.
Duran is a component of a growing group of athletes who’ve recently shared their experiences of mental illness to lift awareness and challenge the stigma. Since its launch in 2014, The Players’ Tribune has been published. More than two dozen athlete essays About mental health, including testimonials from NBA player John Wall and WNBA star A’ja Wilson
Joe Buglewicz/Getty Images
My colleagues and I These revelations have been studied.Public response to them and their social impact. We used surveys, experiments. And interviews Athletes who’ve turn out to be mental health advocates Like 23-time Olympic gold medalist Michael Phelps.
The growing variety of player endorsements coincides with changes in how skilled sports leagues and teams are coping with mental health. Institutions are recruiting. Mental health professionals Advocacy by and Mental health causes in their communities. In a recent evaluation, we found that NFL, MLB and NBA teams made 258 social media posts between 2021 and 2025 advocating for mental health funding, education and policy. Every 12 months the variety of posts increased.
Coupled with when Other results we published in 2020our research shows that sports fans appreciate player testimonials and team-driven conversations. Their response has been overwhelmingly positive. Athletes appear to encourage fans to divulge heart’s contents to family, seek treatment, and take other steps toward their very own well-being.
Vulnerability comes with risks.
Yet Duran’s recent experience illustrates how a minority of fans and sports commentators can threaten that progress.
After the recent incident in Minneapolis, sports and opinion shop Outkick described Duran’s behavior. As an “act” that was “wearing thin”. The response jogged my memory of the criticism leveled at NBA star Ben Simmons a number of years back. In 2021, Simmons began the season with the Philadelphia 76ers, citing mental health issues. A 12 months later, he returned to play for the Brooklyn Nets. Cynics accused him of “Weaponizing mental healthTo avoid playing for the 76ers.
Fans have targeted other players’ mental health issues.
During the 2019 MLB Playoffs, New York Yankees fans caught up. On camera mocking Houston Astros pitcher Zack Greinke for taking medication for his social anxiety disorder as Greinke warmed up. Simone Biles, one in all the best gymnasts of all time, withdrew from competition in the course of the Tokyo Olympics because she experienced “twisties.” The Cleveland Clinic explains. as a “dangerous disconnect between mind and body” as a result of stress and other aspects. Some critics were less sympathetic, Describing it as a quitter.
Prepare for after effects
In addition to being exposed to barbs and verbal abuse, players who speak up about their mental health can be expected to tackle responsibilities they didn’t necessarily enroll for.
Disclosure of mental health struggles can transform an athlete’s popularity from athlete to advocate. For example, social media users debated whether Duran The fans owe it. To share your steps towards recovery. One side argued that doing so would supply guidance to others while legitimizing Duran’s experience. It is none of our business, replied the opposite side.
The label of mental illness also can color people’s judgment of an athlete’s performance. Does throwing his helmet after a strikeout indicate his mental illness, or a transient moment of desperation? Does this decline mean he’s going through one other bout of depression?
Players also worry about whether teammates and coaches will judge them. In 2023, The NCAA conducted the survey. of greater than 2,000 college athletes and located that only half would feel comfortable searching for help for mental health struggles through campus resources. Additionally, only about half believed teammates took the mental health of teammates seriously, and about half felt comfortable discussing their mental health with coaches.
For athletes – or anyone – fascinated with uncovering mental health struggles, a superb game plan may also help speed up positive responses and minimize negative ones.
gave National Coalition on Mental Illness Recommends people – whether or not they’re famous or not – consider the audience, time and amount of data they will easily share. Meanwhile, fans, coaches and teammates can do their part by publicly supporting players who disclose.
When Doran first shared his experiences in 2025, his manager on the time, Alex Cora, immediately signaled his support.
“To do that one needs courage and to be transparent and real,” Cora said. “I hope that’s how we see him — that he’s going to inspire others and that he’s going to save lives.”
With stigma, the battle between silence and dialogue generally is a back-and-forth contest, akin to a protracted rally in tennis or a tense time beyond regulation in basketball. But sometimes all it takes is one decisive moment to alter a game — like when Marcos Torres ripped a line drive to silence his hecklers on that chilly evening in Columbia, South Carolina.